Are you some kind of witch?! I love you! BEST GAME EVER <3 <3 <3
Hi there,Just wanted to say thank you so much for editing this, and making a new version. Really appreciate it. I played the original version with my 6th graders last week (already finished the textbook a while ago), and they loved it, so when I saw a new version I was really happy because I knew they'd want to play it again. For the most part the game went well, however I just wanted to mention the one issue I ran into.For both the "K-pop" and "Listen" section, pretty much all groups got none of the answers right for any of them. Even when I showed them the answers, the reaction was "who?" instead of "oh, right".I know nothing about K-pop so I quickly googled all the songs from those two sections and I found that, with a couple of exceptions (BTS, Itzy) all the songs in those sections date back to somewhere between 2014 and 2017, with a couple songs even going as far back as 2010/2011.My experiences with elementary school students is that, when it comes to K-pop, anything older than a year is ancient history. I've occasionally made the mistake of reusing a ppt from a previous year that included all the "hot" groups from that moment in time, but a year later kids were blinking at these "strangers" like they'd never seen them before.A song from 2015, for a sixth grader, is a song from when they were in 1st grade. Given the disposable nature of the genre, I'm gonna try updating those sections with hits from 2020 and see what happens with other classes.For the Trot section, none of the groups were able to answer any of the questions that were selected, but they did at least seem to recognise the answers. Maybe you chose some classics that have endured through the ages for those questions?Has anyone else tried using this version with elementary school kids? Have you had similar experiences? Am I being an idiot, and this is clearly meant for middle school students? Please let me know. I hope I'm not coming across as having a go at the creator. I appreciate your efforts, I'm just trying to give honest feedback.
